A New CEO, A New Chapter: Governance That Grows With the Organization
A Board Governance Case Study
The situation:
A national education nonprofit spent decades growing under the guidance of a visionary founder and a board deeply committed to his legacy. Over those years, the board and its long-serving chair played a hands-on role in carrying that vision forward, working in close partnership with the organization's leadership.
The arrival of a new CEO marked a natural moment of evolution. She was hired to carry the organization into its next chapter, at a scale its existing structures were not yet built to support. Her arrival also opened a door: a chance for the board to pause, revisit its own role, and decide together what kind of board the organization would need next.
Client Snapshot
Type of Organization: National education nonprofit, built over decades on a founder's vision
Challenges: Leadership transition, founder-era bylaws and policies, board recruitment, redefining the board | CEO relationship
Engagement: Governance review, board interviews, bylaws and policy development, working group facilitation
Timeline: Two-phase engagement, ~10 months
What this moment made possible:
Like many organizations shaped by a founder, this one grew up with a founding, working board: a small, deeply committed group, several of whom were closely involved in the organization's day-to-day life. That model served the organization well for many years. As the organization grew, the board and new CEO saw an opportunity to update governance documents and practices that hadn't kept pace, and to welcome younger, more diverse voices to the board.
Bylaws and policies written in the founding era were few and no longer reflected how the organization operated or where it was headed
Roles between board and staff had developed through long-standing relationships rather than written expectations, and a new CEO created a natural moment to define them
As the organization evolved, the board had a natural opportunity to reflect on its own role, building on its deep, hands-on commitment with a growing focus on strategy and governance
Board composition still reflected the founding era, and there was no defined path for recruiting new members
Before this board could support a new CEO and the organization’s next chapter, it needed to revisit its own role and build the expectations and practices to lead alongside her.
What We Sensed Coming In:
-
How We Shaped The Work Together:
We began with individual conversations with each board member, ahead of any group process, and offered the CEO a thinking partner during the first months of a new role. Those conversations surfaced shared priorities: modern governance documents, clearer roles, and fresh voices at the table.
-
How We Shaped Our Work Together:
We updated the bylaws and policies, added new policies, created a governance handbook for future reference, and framed a new executive committee. Over time, the finance and investment committee had become a de facto executive committee, carrying decisions beyond its financial charge. Framing a dedicated executive committee, with a defined purpose, membership, and authority for the board to put in place after our engagement, gave the board the chance to let the finance and investment committee return to its core fiduciary work, to decide deliberately which matters could be handled between meetings and which belonged with the full board, and to give the chair, officers, and CEO a shared, transparent place to lead together. Decisions could now have a clear home and a clear path back to the whole board.
-
How We Shaped Our Work Together:
We conducted a board survey and board interviews, and facilitated board discussion around term limits, giving the board room to explore how best to reach its goal of diversifying its membership. Rather than adopting term limits right away, the board set an expectation to recruit several new members first and revisit the question once they had joined. New voices would help shape how the board renews itself going forward.
-
How We Shaped The Work Together:
We facilitated forward-looking conversations, structured around scenarios, roles, and what strong governance makes possible, so the board and CEO could shape shared expectations for how they would work together. Starting from the future, rather than the past, gave everyone room to consider how the board could evolve with the organization.
What Changed:
Board members moved from receiving decisions to shaping them through real dialogue
Updated bylaws and policies, gathered in a new governance handbook, gave the board a lasting reference for its next stage of growth
The board set an expectation to recruit several new members, with that work underway as the engagement concluded
Board succession moved from a recognized need to an active, shared priority with term limits on the table once new members join
The CEO had outside support as she began her role, and the board could honor what the founder built while making room to grow beyond it

