Helping a Gridlocked Charter School Organization Rebuild Trust and Adopt a New Curriculum
A Change Management Case Study
The situation:
A small charter management organization (CMO) came to Leading Elephants at a precarious moment. A new CEO had stepped in amid slipping academic results and real financial strain — and the organizational culture underneath was fractured enough that meaningful change felt out of reach.
Client Snapshot
Type of Organization: Charter Management Organization (CMO)
5 Schools: ~ 2,000 students
Challenges: Cultural breakdown, financial strain, curriculum adoption
Engagement: Culture diagnostic, facilitation, leadership coaching, change management
Timeline: ~12 months
“Leading Elephants taught us that hearts matter. Being right with ourselves and each other is critical to meeting our mission of helping kids feel known, loved, supported and educated.”
What the organization was carrying:
This organization had adapted to dysfunction. Every system, habit, and workaround had quietly shaped a culture of resistance over years of leaders feeling unseen and unsupported.
Trust between the central office and its schools had broken down so completely that school leaders had developed code names for central office visits — performing compliance during walkthroughs, then returning to business as usual once leaders left
Past consulting engagements had left leaders fatigued and skeptical, and the instinct was to wait out any new initiative
An entrenched us-versus-them dynamic made honest conversations nearly impossible
Interpersonal tensions and high-drama dynamics were tolerated at every level, quietly undermining problem-solving at every turn
A high-stakes curriculum adoption was on the table, with real potential for impact and real risk of falling flat under weak implementation
The organization was operating in the red, with financial process gaps that raised serious concerns about long-term viability
Sustainable change cannot be layered on top of mistrust. Before this organization could adopt a new curriculum or improve academic results, it had to become the kind of place where real collaboration was possible.
What We Sensed Coming In:
-
How We Shaped The Work Together:
We began by listening broadly across the organization — central office, school leaders, senior team — and produced a culture diagnostic that named what was actually happening: where trust had broken, what pressures leaders were carrying, and what the organization needed to address before any large-scale change could stick. The leadership debrief sessions were raw. Senior leaders encountered hard truths about how their own leadership had shaped the current climate. Several grew emotional describing how hard they had been working and how disconnected they were feeling. Something shifted in those rooms.
-
How We Shaped Our Work Together:
Then, we addressed what was burning. Before addressing any big change agenda, we turned toward the specific flashpoints eroding trust in real time — what we call hot spots. One example: field trip funding had become a symbol of dysfunction between the central office and schools. We facilitated a structured dialogue that surfaced the assumptions, constraints, and historical wounds underneath the issue. The temperature dropped. People leaned forward instead of digging in their heels. By showing willingness to address hot spots, we could make room for the harder strategic questions: what kind of organization did they want to be, and how did they need to lead change differently to get there?
-
How We Shaped Our Work Together:
As trust stabilized, we helped leaders build the skills to sustain it. We offered joint training for central office and school leaders on dialogue across difference, structured problem-solving, and accountability grounded in empathy. Executive coaching created pivotal moments for their change initiative: the CFO found language for the pressure they’d been carrying silently. The CAO crafted a story of change that put their heart back in the work. The CEO de-escalated a volatile situation between two leaders with steadiness that set a new cultural tone. Leading Elephants gradually scaled back as leaders stepped forward in doing the hard work themselves.
“Leading Elephants helped us lean into tough conversations, unwind old stories and resolve ‘hot spots’ to do the important work of transforming kids’ lives together. We still talk about their frameworks for communicating and problem-solving almost weekly — 18 months later.”
What Changed:
Senior leaders stopped operating as embattled victims and stepped into genuine organizational stewardship
Schools moved from performative compliance to productive partnership, welcoming input structures and giving real feedback
Hot-spot flare-ups diminished as shared language and problem-solving practices took root
The curriculum change held — leaders dug into the implementation work rather than searching for the next solution
One high-drama leader self-selected out of the organization, which rebooted the culture of the senior team

