Finding Board Alignment to Better Support Leadership After a Merger and Expansion
A Board Governance and Organizational Alignment Case Study
The situation:
A merged K–12 charter network came to Leading Elephants after making a series of bold organizational moves. Two charter networks, two central offices, two boards, and two distinct histories had been brought together into one organization. A new CEO had taken the helm and the executive team had aligned around a stronger academic strategy. On paper, the merger was working. Early results were promising, and the culture had been refocused around student success and building the right team to deliver it. But the board and CEO were not yet rowing in the same direction. The organization had grown in size, complexity, and ambition. Its governance model had not grown with it.
Client Snapshot
Type of Organization: K–12 charter school network
14 schools; 5,000+ students
Challenges: Post-merger board integration, strained CEO–board relationships, unclear governance roles, differing expectations, and unresolved power dynamics
Engagement: Governance diagnostic, facilitated dialogue, role clarification, governance design, and strategic advising
Timeline: Multi-phase, ~12 months
“Leading Elephants did an expert job at navigating challenging interpersonal dynamics, mediating tensions, and engaging in creative ways to find the pathway forward.”
What the organization was carrying:
Beneath the organization’s visible progress, board members and senior leaders held very different views of what it meant to govern together.
Public scrutiny surrounding the organization had strained relationships and increased defensiveness.
The board and CEO lacked clear, shared expectations about their respective roles and decision-making authority.
Two legacy boards brought different norms, histories, loyalties, and ways of operating into the merged organization.
Board members and organizational leaders were working from different assumptions about what effective oversight and partnership should look like.
Differences in race, positional authority, and power shaped how people experienced conversations and conflict.
The board’s composition and practices still reflected an earlier chapter of the organization rather than the institution it had become.
Unresolved relational tensions were limiting the board’s ability to focus its time and attention on the organization’s most important strategic questions.
The board and CEO needed more than integration. They needed the relationships, expectations, and practices to lead the organization’s next chapter together.
What We Sensed Coming In:
-
How We Shaped The Work Together:
We began by listening across the board and the senior leadership team. The diagnostic process surfaced not only differing views of roles and governance, but also the pain, frustration, and patterns underneath them. People needed a structured way to say what had been difficult, understand how others had experienced the merger, and recognize the assumptions shaping their behavior. Leading Elephants created a container where those realities could be named without allowing the process to become consumed by blame. By acknowledging what people were carrying and building goodwill for more honest conversations, we helped lower the temperature. Repair could begin because people no longer had to pretend that the relationships were already working.
-
How We Shaped Our Work Together:
Board members and leaders had been trying to solve structural questions while still carrying unresolved interpersonal tension. That made every conversation about roles, authority, or expectations feel personal. We helped the group distinguish between two related but different needs: repairing trust and designing the governance model the organization required for its future. Through facilitated dialogue, the board and CEO developed greater clarity about the kind of board the network now needed. They examined where legacy expectations were no longer serving the merged organization and began building a shared picture of effective strategic governance. The work moved from “Whose way will we use?” to “What does this organization need from all of us now?”
-
How We Shaped Our Work Together:
Once the group had greater relational stability and a shared direction, we helped them build what would hold. Together, leaders clarified the respective roles of the board and CEO, identified decision-making lanes, and redesigned governance norms and practices. The work included creating tools that could support current leaders and help future board members enter the organization with greater clarity. Equity values were also translated from broad organizational commitments into concrete governance expectations. The board examined not only what decisions it made, but how authority, voice, and accountability would operate within the partnership and could support the organization’s next chapter.
What Changed:
Board meetings shifted from managing tension toward strategic discussion — time and agendas increasingly centered on the organization's biggest questions.
Commitments to equity became embedded governance practice, shaping how the board approached participation, leadership, accountability, and decision-making.
The organization approached board composition with more intention, thinking ahead about the perspectives, skills, and experience needed for its next chapter.
With clearer boundaries between governance and management, board members could contribute meaningfully without stepping into operational territory.
The CEO could lead with more confidence, spending less energy navigating ambiguity about where the board's role ended and the CEO's began.
New board members joined a more coherent structure — clearer norms and practices helped them orient and contribute faster.
Energy across the board, C-suite, and broader organization aligned more around mission and students, rather than staying caught in governance tension.

