"I'm for You" … Even When I'm Editing Your Work

Giving Feedback on Work Products in Ways That Build

A story from Michelle Hernandez, CEO of Leading Elephants

One especially demanding stretch at Leading Elephants, we were kicking off several year-long series on Leading for Impact, Inclusion, and Belonging, deep in the middle of planning, focus groups, and retreat design. Matching my priorities each week to my actual calendar took some advanced calculus, and every hour counted.

My valued colleague Sandra* had asked me to pick up the first draft of a retreat design. I hadn't planned for it that week, so I spent my Sunday working through framing, activities, and pre-work before sending it to her. Without referencing what I'd painstakingly prepared, Sandra opened our one-on-one Monday with a sharp question about the day's overarching narrative. Then she said, "I was thinking of it this way," and started sketching her own design in a separate Google Doc.

My chest tightened, and my breath went shallow. My mind raced. The story I told myself was that my colleague saw my work as inferior, not worth discussing. I'd wasted a precious weekend day, I told myself, on something she didn't value and might not have even read. We stumbled through the call and eventually realized we agreed on most points, but not before working through some awkward moments.

The next day, reviewing a work product from my direct report Kristie*, I jumped straight in: "I wonder if we might do X in this part, and Y in that section." Then I stopped myself, remembering how I'd felt Monday morning. I put myself in Kristie's shoes and realized how many times I'd been the one opening a conversation with suggested changes, missing the chance to say how strong the draft already was and acknowledge the work behind it.


Feedback Is Situated in a Power Dynamic

As this story shows, power is an undercurrent in so many moments of our work. It can come in multiple forms: the position someone holds, or the social identity markers they carry. In responding to someone's work, there's power simply in being the one giving feedback. The other person has given their all, and the feedback giver can either provide momentum and insight, or wield judgment that the work is "not enough."

Power often feels invisible to the person holding it, which makes it easy to miss how it feels on the receiving end. This is always worth remembering, and it matters even more when the feedback giver also holds positional authority or other social privilege. Michelle's experience was a reminder to stay aware of her own power, and doubly mindful of its impact.

As feedback givers, how thoughtfully we deliver feedback makes all the difference in how these moments play out. These are the moments that build strong bonds and grow our teams. Let's look at the mindsets and actions that make the difference.

A Starting Reminder: "I'm for You" Feedback and the Four Cs

Before we get into the practical side of giving feedback on work products, let's zoom out to the guiding principles behind these moments.

We believe feedback lives inside a relationship, and that the Four Cs, Care, Candor, Curiosity, and Cultural Humility, operate as a true north for dialogue that builds a culture of belonging.

The psychological safety needed for real learning exists when team members feel their managers are "I'm for You," not just for the work product. "I'm for You" feedback means: I honor what you've poured into this, I'm invested in your long-term growth, and I want to find a reasonable balance between how polished this needs to be and everything else you're carrying.

"I'm for You" doesn't mean leaving someone alone to figure it out. Team members consistently say they value clear goals, expectations, and constructive feedback just as much as they value appreciation.

Four Keys to Feedback on Work Products

Here's how we try to put this into practice when we're looking at work together.

1. Acknowledge the Work in the Product

After that Sunday, Michelle truly did want to hear how she could improve what she'd written. She was just tired from pushing hard, and needed someone to say, first, "You put a lot into moving this forward. Thank you."

Consider opening feedback conversations with something like:

  • "I can see how much thought you've put into this. It shows."

  • "I love how you took this early concept and built a whole framework around it. That's real work."

  • "This is exactly the thinking we need more of here. Thank you."

2. Lead With the Headline

Whether we're three years old showing off a finger painting or forty and sharing a first white paper, part of us just wants to know: how did I do? Getting the big picture first, before the details, lets people settle into the conversation instead of scanning for where it's headed.

Try something like:

  • "This report is strong. I have a couple of things I'd love to talk through, but we're in good shape to send this out tomorrow."

  • "You've built some solid pieces here. I think there's more work to do on X, landing the close or sharpening the framework, and I'd love to share some ideas."

  • "I can see the shape of the idea taking form in this first draft. We're probably a couple of rounds from final, and I'm looking forward to digging into X, Y, and Z with you."

3. Name Your Key Priorities Out Loud

Anyone with a detailed eye, and a few years of experience, can probably spot a hundred things they'd have done differently. But an "I'm for You" stance treats a person's growth and sense of ownership as just as important as any single work product. Help your team see the forest, not just the trees, by choosing three or so themes that matter most, explaining why they matter, and staying open to exploring different ways to get there together.

A few examples of feedback we've given recently:

  • "It matters to me that leaders can see themselves in what we publish. I'd like more empathy for the reader in this paragraph, some acknowledgment that leadership is hard. What are some ways we could bring that in?"

  • "In our leaders' session, I want managers to walk away seeing that one-on-ones aren't just a nice-to-have, they're where barriers get cleared and momentum gets built. How might we use examples or scenarios that show that?"

  • "This retreat is a real opportunity for our virtual team to build deeper connection. Could we find ways to connect personally before we move into strategic direction?"

4. Agree Together on How to Handle the Small Stuff

While the conversation should focus on the few themes that matter most, there are usually smaller things too: a clunky sentence, a suggestion someone could take or leave. This is where feedback tends to go one of two ways: it becomes overbearing and demoralizing, or it stays so hands-off that people miss the insight they're actually craving.

A few things worth considering as you decide how to handle the small stuff:

  • How perfect does this actually need to be? Many of us grew up in workplaces with one uniform standard of excellence. Applying that same standard to everything is part of what drives the exhaustion so common in our field. Often, the most useful thing a leader can do is name clearly when "good enough" really is good enough.

  • Where does this person want to grow, or want feedback? One of our team members is great at saying, "I'm uncertain about X and would love your ideas. On Y, I've already been through several rounds, so just flag anything that's a real concern." Knowing what someone is actually looking for makes feedback so much more useful.

  • What are this person's feedback preferences right now? Sometimes people are hungry to learn and want every suggestion they can get. Other times, they're running on empty and would be relieved if you just made the small changes yourself.

This is where "I'm for You" really gets tested. Deciding together, consciously, how much feedback to give and how, is what lets feedback build strong work and a motivated team at the same time.

Feedback on Work Products Can Be a Culture-Builder

Feedback can be one of the strongest building blocks of a thriving culture. It can also be the last straw for a team member who doesn't feel seen. Feedback looks simple on the surface, but it's remarkable how often experienced leaders, ourselves included, go on autopilot and miss the mark.

When we slip into old habits, we lose an easy chance to tune in to the other person, to focus on what matters most for both the work and their growth, and to feed the cycle of motivation, belonging, and performance that good feedback can build.



*Names and identifying details in this story have been changed to protect confidentiality.

Previous
Previous

A Crushing Recipe for White Supremacy Culture in Change

Next
Next

The Pursuit of Vitality Over Chaos and Overdrive